About us
A real card shop, not a warehouse
The Card Shop sits in Plattsburgh Plaza with a counter full of sealed wax, singles binders and a case of graded slabs. We're collectors first — the kind of shop where you can ask what a card is actually worth and get a straight answer.
Buy · Sell · Trade
Bring it in
Walk in during open hours with whatever you've got — a binder, a shoebox, a storage tote. No appointment required.
We take a look
We sort, check condition, and pull anything of note. Small lots take a few minutes; big collections we'll set aside time for.
Cash or credit
Take a cash offer, or take more in store credit and put it straight toward something in the case.
What we take
- Vintage and modern sports cards
- Pokémon singles, sealed and bulk
- Magic: The Gathering collections
- Graded slabs — PSA, BGS, CGC
- Complete sets and factory sets
- Memorabilia and collectibles
Got something to sell?
Call ahead for large collections and we'll clear the table for you.
(518) 566-4009